Fat Toad's Pub - Farmingdale, Maine

Ally D.

I was disappointed in the menu, as it seemed like they offered far less than what Google showed. Turns out, for whatever reason they just don't list everything on the actual menu. There are little white boards in various places that show other options, from appetizers and snacks to lunch and dinner specials. We would both have rather had some of those things vs what we settled for off the official laminated menu.

With that said, his burger and fries were great, and I really enjoyed the stuffed grape leaves. I didn't love the shawarma, but I didn't hate it, either.

The pub itself is adorable, very nice atmosphere, cute bar vibe in the front and a cozy lodge feel in the back.

The staff were all wonderful, accommodating, efficient, and helpful.

I would absolutely visit again. Just fyi there's way more to the menu than the little laminated sheet they hand you, so don't think Google lied, lol.

Alicia N.

This was our second time here. It's a great little local place. When we walked in, everyone turned and said hello, even though they don't know us. Same when we left, the bartender, also our server, said bye, and those as the bar did the same! The bartender was very friendly, talking and joking around with us. Just a great atmosphere!!

Ophelia B.

The pub food is good but the secret gem of this place is the authentic Lebanese food! Omg it's sooooo good! The stuffed grape leaves are amazing and they have daily specials that are the star of the show.
Perfect place when half your group wants beer and wings but the other half wants real ethnic food and a nice balcony to dine on.
Definitely a hidden treasure!

Adam F.

I love this place. It has always been a good in terms of pub food, but the new owners have also added some Lebanese specials to the menu. They still sell great pub food, but I’ve never been disappointed by the Lebanese offerings. The shawarma has been my favorite so far, but they frequently add new dishes that I like to try. The owners are very friendly and provide great service. They draw a good crowd on the deck on Wednesday when they have live music. Prices are very reasonable.

Thomas F.

Went here for lunch today for the second time in a month, as you can see by the review, it was great! This place is the definition of a neighborhood bar. Staffing is small, so don't expect a "city" experience. Enjoy

Richard D.

I recently visited Fat Toad's Pub and I must say that I was completely blown away! This tiny pub may be small in size, but it certainly packs a big punch in terms of food and atmosphere. The menu options were outstanding, with a variety of delectable dishes that catered to all kinds of dietary requirements. From the pub's signature burgers to their mouth-watering Lebanese options, the food was absolutely amazing.
The atmosphere was cozy and inviting, with a warm and welcoming vibe that made me feel right at home. The staff were friendly and attentive, making sure that my experience was nothing short of perfect. Overall, Fat Toad's Pub is a little hidden gem that I would highly recommend to anyone looking for a great meal and a relaxed atmosphere. If you're in the area, do yourself a favor and stop by – you won't be disappointed! I give this place a solid 5-star rating and can't wait to come back for more!

Christine B.

A fun roadside spot with great food and a friendly atmosphere. The staff go above and beyond for their customers and have the best attitudes. I have seen the same people there in multiple visits so a great locals pub. The food is always delicious, the service fast and the drinks strong.

D A. D.

Don't be deceived by the appearance of this place from the outside, as once you step inside, you will be greeted by two incredibly warm and friendly brothers. Their menu offers a wide variety of options, but what delighted me the most was their authentic homemade Lebanese cuisine. The cleanliness of the place is also worth mentioning, as I observed their meticulous attention to detail while they cleaned. I am eager to revisit this establishment and would wholeheartedly recommend it to others.